A view into the mind of Jason

Welcome to Evilness
Friday, April 19 2024 @ 04:49 MDT

Blow to antivaxers

Jason ramblingOne would hope that the retraction of the Wakefield et al. (1998) by the medical journal The Lancet would stop the antivax movement in its tracks, given that Wakefield (1998) is the basis of the whole vaccine-causes-autism woo. It won't, of course, since the antivax community is dogmatically set in its ways in the manner of a religious fanatic. No amount of evidence from sources that used actual epidemiological studies (Taylor et al 1999, DeStefano & Chen 1999, DeStefano & Chen 2000, Gillberg & Heijbel 1998, Peltola et al 1998) will dissuade them from their firmly held belief. The danger in this lies in the fact that these people will continue to attempt to force their views on an unsuspecting public. There are two large dangers in this apart from the basic attack on science that I've discussed before.

The first danger is the obvious, that of large numbers of children will go unvaccinated. This not only puts individual children at risk of death from easily preventable childhood diseases, but the rest of society as well due to the reduction in herd immunity. This means many thousands will suffer needlessly and hundreds may needlessly die. All because of an unevidenced belief held with religious tenacity.

The second and more insidious danger is that to autistic children. By diverting resources into attempting to proved what has been shown to not be there, the antivax crowd is diverting resources away from productive autism research. This means that resources that could have gone to determine what factors actually cause autism are being sent to study something that we already know isn't causing autism. This causes a delay in more productive autism research causing the exact opposite of what I imagine the parents of autistic children want, which would be a better understanding of the condition.

Unfortunately the antivax zealots will continue on unphased by their legs being pulled out from under them. They're like the Black Knight in Monty Python's Holy Grail who despite having his legs and arms cut off continues to attack. All we can do is to continue to educate the public that they are being deceived by the antivax crowd. This will act as a vaccine in society causing the antivaxers to go the way of smallpox.

References:

DeStefano, F. & Chen, R.T., 1999, Lancet, 353 1987

DeStefano, F. & Chen, R.T., 2000, J Pediatr, 2000, 136 125

Gillberg, C. & Heijbel, H., 1998, Autism, 2 423

Taylor, B. et al, 1999, Lancet, 353 2026

Wakefield, AJ, et al, 1998, Lancet, 351 637

Blow to antivaxers | 4 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.
Blow to antivaxers
Authored by: Anonymous onFriday, February 05 2010 @ 01:00 MST
The cynic in me says
"Well we need to decrease world population numbers and if the gulible and the religious fanatics die off it might be a better place."

However, the educator in me says
"No! we must educate the unknowning masses so they will understand enough to make the correct decision and not be swayed by pseudo-science."

Saddly there is enough misunderstanding about vaccines that even some very educated people are swayed by the antivax campaigners..... perhaps we do need another epidemic to set everyone's heads straight about what is really important in the world.

All I've ever had to do was ask my folks - as they both lived through some major epidemics - TB, polio, one of the more deadly flu epidemics....
Heck my aunt lost the use of her hand during the polio epidemic. They are of a generation that understood the good that vaccines brought to a community in a very visceral way, it's too bad that we are slowly loosing the knowledge from that generation.